gltsoi (gltsoi) wrote,

St. Louis Eats, VII

Tony’s, Downtown

Tony’s is described with terms like “legendary,” “venerated” and “landmark,” and the ratings for service are very high. It seemed like a good place to have our traditional “End-of-Nationals” meal.

The host informed Steve that he needed a jacket for the dining room and gave him a loaner blazer. The website says business causal, but the host explained it is more formal on Saturday nights. I would be weirded out by wearing a loaner jacket, but Steve seemed to take it all in stride. Luckily, I was in a dress and heels.

We started with seared sea scallops with a black truffle sauce. This appetizer made it on to St. Louis Magazine’s “50 best dishes” and the accolade was well deserved. I thought my scallop was excellent, but for $13, I’m not sure if $6.50 a scallop is reasonable. The homemade penne with mushrooms and asparagus ($11) was also delicious. The bread basket also had a nice variety of focaccia, crostini, olive bread and ciabatta.

Steve had the veal rib chop with eggplant. It came as a giant, flat, pounded piece of veal with a eggplant parm layer atop it. We didn’t feel it was terribly flavorful nor interesting. If I was paying $17 at Carlo’s Cucina Italiana in Brighton, I would have been content, but at $38, I was expecting a lot more finesse. His potatoes were also under cooked.


My grilled filet of halibut ($33) was fine – I liked the lemon caper sauce. Steve thought my fish was underdone, but I enjoyed it.


The service was excellent; all of our food was cooked in the kitchen, but finished tableside on kerosene burners. I didn’t really see the point of this. It’s one thing when you are making a cherries jubilee or something that requires flaming, but mostly I just worried that my food was getting overcooked.

Lucas Park Grille, Downtown

We finished our game late on Sunday and the ground was covered in 4”+ of snow. I was grateful just to find somewhere open for dinner. Lucas Park Grille far exceeded my expectations. The space is really nice, divided in to different areas. We sat near a roaring fireplace. We had the duck leg confit to share. It came with a nice raspberry sauce and arugula.


My meatloaf, garlic mashed potatoes and green beans ($15) hit the bull’s-eye in my comfort food spot.


Steve polished off his smoked pepper grilled pork chop ($20). The prices were reasonable and our server was great. She didn’t seem to mind waiting for us to close the place up.
Tags: italian, new american, restaurant review, st. louis
  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.