gltsoi (gltsoi) wrote,

Grandma Ethel Sole’s soft ginger cookies, er, I mean cake.

I have a ginger molasses cookie recipe from Cook’s Illustrated that I really love and I brought it in to work for the annual cookie swap. My friend Carol P. (not to be confused with my other friend, Carol W.) told me about a ginger cookie that her ex-husband’s grandmother used to make. She got the recipe, but could not make heads or tails of the half written directions on the index card. I told her to bring it in and I would have a look.

This is what she brought me:


My favorite line is “flour to handle,”

Carol is currently taking time away from work to help her husband recover, post-surgery, so I thought I would stop by with a batch of Grandma Sole’s cookies. As you can see, the card does not include directions, so I started combining the ingredients in a traditional cookie method (cream the fat and sugar, add egg, add the rest of liquid. Combine dry ingredients, add to wet.) It was all going well – I creamed the shortening and sugar together, added the molasses, added the eggs and then got ready to add the 1 cup cold coffee. I looked at the batter and knew instinctively that it was not going to work – the batter would not absorb a whole cup of liquid. If had had followed my gut, I would have swapped instant espresso power for the coffee, keeping the flavor without adding additional moisture. But, I told myself to have faith in Grandma Sole and dumped it in. Disaster. The fat/sugar mixture seized up and curdled immediately. I swapped the paddle attachment on the mixer for the whisk and whipped it for a good 5 minutes, and the coffee marginally incorporated itself. I decided to forge ahead with the dry ingredients. I started with 2 cups of flour and it became clear I was not getting cookie batter – the consistency was completely wrong. I added an additional ½ cup of flour and realized it was closer to cake batter. I shrugged and prepped a 9x13 cake pan. I guesstimated 40 minutes in a 350 degree oven and when I checked at 38 minutes with a toothpick, it was done.

I allowed it to cool and cut myself a small piece. I was shocked that the texture was light, moist and tender. The flavor was grown-up; dark, roasty and a little bitter from the molasses and coffee. This was not a 6 year old’s birthday cake. I felt like it needed some additional sweetness, so I whipped up a batch of my favorite cream cheese frosting and it complimented the cake perfectly. So, there you have it, Grandma Sole’s ginger cookies, er cake.

photo 4 (2)

photo 3 (2)
Tags: cake, cookie, recipe
  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.